Nirvati vs. YunoHost
Below, we compare Nirvati with YunoHost, a Debian-based server distribution for self-hosting with a web admin, a user portal and single sign-on. Nirvati is built in an open spirit, with free and open source licenses, and with a strong focus on security. We describe YunoHost by facts you can check, with sources where possible. Where YunoHost offers something Nirvati doesn't, we say so: it is open source as well, and it includes a mail server, single sign-on and integrated backups.
Select any row to read the details and our sources.
LicenseYunoHost: Open source (AGPL-3.0)Nirvati: Open source (AGPL-3.0)
The YunoHost core is licensed under the AGPL-3.0, and its app catalog under the GPL-3.0. YunoHost only accepts apps based on free software into its catalog. Nirvati is licensed under the AGPL-3.0 as well.
Sources: YunoHost license, YunoHost app catalog license, YunoHost catalog rules, Nirvati backend
App permissions & isolationYunoHost: Install scripts run as root, the rest is up to package reviewNirvati: Enforced by Nirvati
A YunoHost app package consists of a manifest and Bash scripts for installing, upgrading, backing up, restoring and removing the app. YunoHost runs these scripts as root, and they install the app directly on the Debian system, next to all other apps. At runtime, apps typically run as their own system user with restricted capabilities, which each package sets up. What a package does is checked by package review and automated tests, not enforced by YunoHost. YunoHost's documentation names stronger confinement of apps as a future goal.
In Nirvati, every app runs in its own Kubernetes namespace. Nirvati works out which permissions an app needs from its definition: privileged containers, host folders, extra capabilities or host networking require built-in permissions, which you have to grant when you install the app, and only users with the right to install such apps can grant them. Network policies limit which apps can talk to each other, and apps can only use another app's services if they have the permission to.
Sources: YunoHost script execution, YunoHost app installation, YunoHost app system users, YunoHost security docs, Nirvati permission checks, Nirvati install permissions, Nirvati network policies
Number of appsYunoHost: About 700 working appsNirvati: 34 in FOSS Apps, plus umbrelOS and Tipi apps
At the time of writing, the YunoHost catalog lists 727 apps, 700 of them marked as working. An automated test suite rates every app on a quality level from 0 to 8, and a security index marks app versions with known vulnerabilities.
Nirvati's FOSS Apps repository currently lists 34 apps, next to the Nirvati Essentials repository. Through compatibility apps, Nirvati can also run apps from umbrelOS app stores and Tipi apps.
Sources: YunoHost app catalog, YunoHost quality levels, YunoHost security index, Nirvati app store
Apps from other platformsYunoHost: NoNirvati: Yes, from umbrelOS and Tipi
YunoHost apps are packaged specifically for YunoHost. Nirvati can run apps from umbrelOS app stores and Tipi apps through compatibility apps.
Choosing an app's version when installingYunoHost: Only from a Git commit, by handNirvati: Yes
The YunoHost catalog points to one version of each app. An older version can only be installed by installing the package from a specific Git branch or commit on the command line. In Nirvati, you can choose which version of an app to install.
Source: YunoHost catalog handling
Third-party app storesYunoHost: Yes, configured on the serverNirvati: Yes, fully integrated
YunoHost supports additional app catalogs, which are configured in a file on the server. We found no option to add them in the web admin. You can also install an app directly from a Git repository, after confirming a warning. In Nirvati, third-party app stores are part of the system's main app store.
Sources: YunoHost catalogs, YunoHost install warnings
Multi-user supportYunoHost: YesNirvati: Yes
YunoHost stores users and groups in an LDAP directory, and every user gets an email address. Nirvati supports multiple users, each with their own apps and domains.
Sources: YunoHost users, YunoHost permissions
Who installs appsYunoHost: Admins, for everyoneNirvati: Every user with the permission to
On YunoHost, admins install apps for the whole server and decide which users and groups can use each app. In Nirvati, every user with the permission to manage apps installs their own apps.
Source: YunoHost permissions
User roles and permissionsYunoHost: Admins and users, access per app for users and groupsNirvati: Fine-grained permissions and groups
YunoHost has users, groups and an admins group. Admins give users and groups access to individual apps, to extra areas of an app such as its admin pages, and to SSH or SFTP. In Nirvati, you can give each user specific permissions, for example to manage apps, domains or users, and organize users in groups.
Source: YunoHost permissions
Single sign-on for appsYunoHost: Yes, with its portal and LDAPNirvati: No, login protection in front of apps
YunoHost's single sign-on layer checks in front of every app whether the user is allowed to use it, and passes the signed-in user on to apps that support it. Apps can also sign users in against the LDAP directory directly. YunoHost doesn't include an OpenID Connect provider; its documentation lists it as a goal.
Nirvati has no built-in single sign-on for apps. You can protect an app, so anyone opening it first signs in with their Nirvati account. Identity providers such as Keycloak and Zitadel are available as apps.
Sources: YunoHost permissions, YunoHost single sign-on announcement, YunoHost security docs
Email serverYunoHost: Yes, built inNirvati: No, available as an app
YunoHost includes a complete mail server with Postfix, Dovecot and Rspamd, and every user gets an email address. Nirvati doesn't include a mail server. You can install the Stalwart mail server from the app store.
Source: YunoHost users
Integrated backupsYunoHost: Yes, encrypted remote backups through appsNirvati: No, app snapshots only
YunoHost can back up the system and apps into archives on the server or on an external disk. These archives aren't encrypted. The BorgBackup and Restic apps add encrypted, scheduled backups to remote storage. Before every app upgrade, YunoHost makes a backup and restores it automatically if the upgrade fails.
Nirvati can take snapshots of apps, but doesn't have an integrated backup feature yet.
Sources: YunoHost backups, YunoHost backup methods, YunoHost backup code, YunoHost app upgrades
PasskeysYunoHost: NoNirvati: Yes
Nirvati supports signing in with passkeys. YunoHost doesn't.
Source: YunoHost security docs
Free domainYunoHost: Yes, one per serverNirvati: Yes, a nirvati.me subdomain for every user
YunoHost offers one free subdomain per server on nohost.me, noho.st or ynh.fr. It points to your server's public IP address, so visitors reach your server over the internet, usually through port forwarding on your router.
During setup, Nirvati offers every user a free nirvati.me subdomain with HTTPS. The domain can point to your server's address in Nirvati Connect, Tailscale or your local network, so only your devices can reach it.
Source: YunoHost DynDNS
Automatic DNS setup for your own domainsYunoHost: Yes, about 90 DNS providersNirvati: Yes, Cloudflare, or Bunny.net through an app
Both systems support your own domains. YunoHost can set up their DNS records automatically with about 90 DNS providers. Nirvati has a built-in integration for Cloudflare, and Bunny.net is available through an app.
Sources: YunoHost DNS providers, YunoHost DNS code
Certificates without a public IP addressYunoHost: NoNirvati: Yes, with a DNS integration
YunoHost gets certificates from Let's Encrypt with HTTP validation, so Let's Encrypt has to reach your server on port 80. With a DNS integration, Nirvati issues wildcard certificates from Let's Encrypt, also when your server has no public IP address.
Source: YunoHost certificates
VPN for remote accessYunoHost: Via apps (WireGuard, Headscale, ZeroTier)Nirvati: Built in: Nirvati Connect or Tailscale
YunoHost has no built-in remote access. Its catalog has apps such as a WireGuard server, Headscale and ZeroTier, and a VPN client app that routes your server through a VPN provider. Nirvati includes Nirvati Connect, which is free without limits. Your server signs every change to your network, and the hosted service only relays encrypted data. Tailscale is supported as well.
Source: YunoHost app catalog
Multi-server supportYunoHost: NoNirvati: Yes, with Nirvati OS
With Nirvati OS, you can add servers to your Nirvati from the dashboard. All servers form one cluster, your apps run across them, and with three control-plane servers, the cluster keeps working if one of them fails. YunoHost runs on a single Debian server.
Hardware requirementsYunoHost: 512 MB RAM, 16 GB storageNirvati: 4 GB RAM, 40 GB storage
YunoHost runs with 512 MB of RAM and 16 GB of storage, also on 32-bit PCs and on the Raspberry Pi 3. Nirvati needs at least 4 GB of RAM and 40 GB of storage.
Source: YunoHost installation docs
Base systemYunoHost: Debian, apps installed nativelyNirvati: Kubernetes
YunoHost installs apps directly on Debian, with nginx and systemd services. Nirvati runs apps on Kubernetes, which makes multi-server setups and isolation between apps possible.
ImagesYunoHost: x86 PCs (64 and 32 bit), Raspberry Pi, any Debian systemNirvati: UEFI PCs (x86_64, arm64), Raspberry Pi, Radxa Orion O6N
YunoHost offers images for x86 PCs and for the Raspberry Pi 3, 4 and 5. On other ARM boards and on cloud servers, you install YunoHost on top of Debian or Armbian. Nirvati OS offers images for PCs and servers with UEFI (x86_64 and arm64), Raspberry Pi and Radxa Orion O6N.
Sources: YunoHost images, YunoHost installation
Security architecture
The table above compares single features. This section looks at how both systems are built to keep your server, your apps and your data safe.
Isolation between appsYunoHost: Same host, no network isolation foundNirvati: Own namespace per app, network policies
On YunoHost, all apps run on the same Debian host and listen on local ports, and nginx forwards requests to them. We found no network isolation between apps. YunoHost's firewall only controls incoming connections from outside.
On Nirvati, every app runs in its own Kubernetes namespace. Cilium network policies define which apps and services an app can reach, and an app can only use another app's services if it has the permission to.
Sources: YunoHost firewall, Nirvati network policies
Isolation from the hostYunoHost: Decided by package reviewNirvati: Enforced when installing
On YunoHost, every app's install, upgrade, backup, restore and remove scripts run as root on the host. At runtime, packages usually run the app as its own system user with restricted capabilities. YunoHost doesn't enforce limits on what a package may do.
On Nirvati, each app's namespace gets a Kubernetes Pod Security level. Privileged containers, host folders, extra capabilities and host networking require built-in permissions that you grant when you install the app, and only users who may install such apps can grant them. Apps from the umbrelOS and Tipi compatibility layers run with the Privileged Pod Security level, but anything privileged they actually use still needs such a permission. Hook scripts of umbrelOS apps run in an isolated container.
Sources: YunoHost script execution, YunoHost security docs, Nirvati namespaces, Nirvati permission checks, Nirvati umbrelOS compatibility
Login before opening an appYunoHost: Yes, with access per user and groupNirvati: Yes
Both systems can ask you to sign in before an app opens. On YunoHost, the single sign-on layer checks whether the signed-in user or one of their groups has access to the app. On Nirvati, you can protect an app, so anyone opening it first signs in with their Nirvati account.
Source: YunoHost permissions
Isolation between usersYunoHost: Shared apps, access per appNirvati: Separate apps, namespaces and permissions
On YunoHost, apps are installed once for the whole server, and admins decide which users and groups can use them. On Nirvati, each user installs their own apps into their own namespaces, and what a user may do is controlled by fine-grained permissions.
Remote accessYunoHost: Public IP address, or VPN appsNirvati: Nirvati Connect, signed by your server
On YunoHost, you usually reach your server through its public IP address, or set up remote access with an app such as WireGuard, Headscale or ZeroTier.
With Nirvati Connect, your server signs every change to your private network, and devices only join with a code from your server. The hosted service can't add devices or change rules, device names, IP addresses, policies, routes and DNS settings are encrypted, and traffic between devices is end-to-end encrypted with WireGuard. Tailscale is supported too.
Signed updatesYunoHost: System updates from signed Debian repositoriesNirvati: With Nirvati OS
YunoHost installs system and core updates from Debian package repositories, which apt verifies with signatures. App packages are fetched from Git at the revision listed in the catalog, and the source files of an app are checked against the SHA-256 checksums in its package. Nirvati OS only installs an update if its manifest carries a valid signature from Nirvati's release key, which is built into the system. The manifest contains the SHA-256 checksums of all files of the update. On other Linux systems, Nirvati doesn't verify signatures of updates yet.
Sources: YunoHost app catalog handling, YunoHost app sources, Nirvati OS updates
Encryption at restYunoHost: Optional, set up by hand when installing DebianNirvati: Full disk encryption with Nirvati OS
On YunoHost, you can encrypt your disk with LUKS by partitioning it in the expert mode of the Debian installer. You then enter the passphrase every time the server starts.
Nirvati OS encrypts the full disk. An installation of Nirvati on a standard Linux system is considered unencrypted.
Source: YunoHost installation docs
TorYunoHost: Not built inNirvati: Tor for apps with permission, onion domains
We found no built-in Tor support in YunoHost. On Nirvati, the Tor support app lets apps send requests through Tor if they have the permission to, and you can add onion domains for your apps. Nirvati also sends telemetry through Tor, if you opted in.